You are currently browsing comments. If you would like to return to the full story, you can read the full entry here: “ Bike Gate by Merwyn Wijaya and Teo Kok ”.
It’s not innovative, its just stupid!!! Any NYC biker knows, that you have to lock the bike in such a way that locks both wheels, otherwise you comeback to a bike with no wheels.
This is perhaps the worst design for bike racks that I’ve ever seen. The biggest red flag is the inconsistency between “greater security” and “abandoned bikes”. People don’t abandon perfectly good bikes that were kept secure. The main reason bikes get abandoned is because, like Roman said, components go missing and the owner calculates that they’re just better off getting a new bike along with a better locking mechanism.
This thing seems designed to *expose* everything but the frame to easy theft. Worse, a compromise of the vaunted “key lock mechanism” would allow thieves to take any bike from any installation of this thing. This is an anti-security design. Just awful.
Great idea! This would improve on the old lamp post! Anyone needing greater security will be bringing their own locks anyway. Might be tough getting to that middle bike, though. Maybe just in pods of two so everyone can get to his/her bike. One would suppose that a nested, Lexan clear plastic cover would use a similar flip down device over the top and satisfy even the most ardent security nuts, eh?
The lack of wheel engagement is a deal breaker, but so is the lack of any apparent way to keep the bikes upright. They’ll just fall over sideways with the side of the ‘gate’ sticking through the triangle.
Being rather fond of non-DF bikes, my Moulton just might fit, but my recumbents (past, present, and future) would not. And with overlapping handlebars, removing one’s bike could get interesting.
The “Dual Locking” feature only requires one of the mechanisms to be broken and both locks are disabled.
Remember that these guys are from Singapore where crime levels are pretty low and punishments severe so they are probably not used to London levels of crime where the thieves will have your saddle and pedals if you have the audacity to use a lock they can’t get through and stolen bikes are sold with impunity in the Brick Lane thieves market only a few days (hours?) after they are nicked with little interest from the authorities.